Many people dislike and mistrust backroom deals and old boys networks in government. They prefer open and transparent governance. It makes for better institutions, and a better human condition. I am one of those people. Since you’re reading this, chances are you are, too.
Like many of those people, I watched the global Internet rise and saw an opportunity. I put a lot of work into exploring how Internet-enabled communication could make democracy better and smarter. Most of that work was practical. It consisted of designing and delivering open government projects, first in Italy (Kublai, Visioni Urbane, both links in Italian) and later in Europe (Edgeryders). Since 2006, I have kept in touch with my peers who, all over the world, were working on these topics. Well, I have news: this debate is now shifting. We are no longer talking about the things we talked about in 2009. If you care about democracy, this is both good and bad news. Either way, it’s big and exciting.
Back in the late 2000s, we thought the Internet would improve the way democracy worked by lowering the costs of coordination across citizens. This worked across the board. It made everything easier. Transparency? Just put the information on a website, make it findable by search engines. Participation? Online surveys are dirt cheap. Citizens-government collaboration? Deploy fora and wikis; take advantage of the Net’s ubiquity to attract to them the people with the relevant expertise. We had the theory; we had (some) practice. We were surfing the wave of the Internet’s unstoppable diffusion. When Barack Obama made President of the United States in 2008, we also had the first global leader who stood by these principles, in word and deed. We were winning.
We expected to continue winning. We had a major advantage: open government did not need a cultural shift to get implemented. Adoption of new practices was not a revolution: it was a retrofit. We would use words familiar to the old guard: transparency, accountability and participation. They were like talismans. Senior management would not always show enthusiasm, but they could hardly take position against those values. Once our projects were under way, then they caused cultural shifts. Public servants learned to work in an open, collaborative way. Later, they found it hard to go back to the old ways of information control and need-to-know. So, we concluded, this can only go one way: towards more Internet in government, more transparency, participation, collaboration. The debate reflected this, with works like Beth Noveck’s The Wiki Government (2009) and my own Wikicrazia (2010).
All that’s changed now.
What brought the change home was reading two recent books. One is Beth Noveck’s Smart Citizens, Smarter Governance. The other is Complexity and the Art of Public Policy, by David Colander and Roland Kupers. I consider these two books an advance on anything written before on the matter.
Beth is a beacon for us opengov types. She pioneered open governments practices in a project called Peer2Patents. Because of that, President Obama recruited her on his transition team first, and to the White House proper later. She has a ton of experience at all levels, from theory to project delivery to national policy making. And she has a message for us: Open Government is failing. Here’s the money quote:
Despite all the enthusiasm for and widespread recognition of the potential benefits of more open governance, the open government movement has had remarkably little effect on how we make public decisions, solve problems, and allocate public goods.
Why is that? The most important proximate cause is that government practices are encoded in law. Changing them is difficult, and does need a cultural shift so that lawmakers can pass reforms. The ultimate cause is what she calls professionalized government. The reasoning goes like this:
- Aligning information with decision making requires curation of information, hence expertise.
- The professions have long served as a proxy for expertise. Professionalized government is new in historical terms, but it has now set in.
- So, “going open is a call to exercise civic muscles that have atrophied”.
- When professions set in, they move to exclude non-members from what they consider their turf. Everybody important in government is by now a professional, and mistrusts the potential of common citizens to contribute. And everybody reinforces everybody else’s convictions in this sense. So, you get a lot of “meaningless lip service to the notion of engagement”, but little real sharing of power.
Really interesting, thanks.
My question to you is not directly related to complexity.
Beth’s professional database looks a lot like LinkedIn and their project for a skills’ graph.
It’s worth noting that the most complete collections of data about people interests and competencies is owned by (US) private corporations. Add to this data on social networks, search engine queries, preferences on all sort of topics. They build world-level “policies” on their own while the govs are just starting to build a data driven system.
How is going policy making to be mixed with a so powerful data capitalism?
Piero
Hello Piero, I may not be the most qualified person to give answers on Beth’s candidate solution. The book quotes extensively a project called Aristotle (abandoned). Based on that, it looks like it might start out as a silo; she mentions the needs of the Food and Drugs Administration to quickly reach WITHIN THEIR OWN RANKS for experts on certain molecules that need vetting. This would already improve FDA’s efficiency. Then, such a system could be opened up to non-employees and scaled up. But I may well be wrong in this.
Thank you 🙂