Just a very short post to report I just finished Robert Jackson Bennett’s A Trade of Blood. And what a nice surprise it was to find the author engaging with the political economy underpinning the Khanum empire, the captivating world he has built for his fantasy detecive novels of the Ana and Din series.
Bennett has become one of my favourite speculative fiction authors in later years – since, that is, I laid eyes on his Divine Cities novels. He writes well, his characters are outstanding, his worldbuilding intriguing and genre-defining. What he did not do in Divine Cities, nor in the first two Ana and Din novels, was look into matters of production, distribution and consumption (based on the reviews, it looks like he did that more in another trilogy, called Founders, but I have not yet read that). So, I was delighted to see him foreground it in A Trade of Blood, with at least one character explicitly trying to dismantle the economic engine of the Third Ring of the Empire!
The post is short because Bennett does not try to imagine an “alien economy” different from our own. He uses speculative fiction as a mirror to reflect and criticize the economic system we are already living in, late-stage capitalism. This is an operation similar to those of most (but not all) cyberpunk authors, including their doyen William Gibson. The difference is that A Trade of Blood focuses on a specific production sector: cattle farming.
Just like our world, the Khanum empire consumes a lot of meat, produced in the breadbasket lands of the Third Ring. This trade brings much prosperity to some, but again much like or world, it also entails great suffering of the animals, and massive inefficiencies, as vast expanses of prime farming land is given to growing plants usable as fodder. Additionally, meat production is downright dangerous: production is underpinned by the use of risky, unstable biotechnologies. Everybody sees the problems, but change is difficult; the families who enriched themselves in the flesh trade are powerful, and eating meat is a signifier of abundance and hospitality. Even the opposition of the Orbiis, the branch of the imperial military dedicated to environmental stewardship, was shrugged off.
A critical position on our own economy through speculative fiction is not yet economic science fiction in my view, My favourite economic speculative fiction novels speculate: they build economies that function differently from our own. But Bennett’s critique is a start, one by an incredibly gifted author. So I will take it and applaud him, and hope that the next Ana and Din will bring us to some corner of the empire where people engage in commons-based peer production, or have built up monastic economies, or some such.