Posted in

Mortgaging democracy: on tax cuts for the rich, the fiscal crisis and the rise of inequalities

Firefighters in the Gironde region in France in 20206. Photo credit: Mael Dubie/EPA/Shutterstock

In a recent conversation with Paul Krugman, public economist Vanessa Williamson revisits the transformation of the United States from a country with high, and highly progressive income taxes in the 1970s to one with neither. I knew the basic outline of the story from Thomas Piketty’s striking graphs scattered all over Capital in the 21st Century, but I did not know how that had come to pass. According to Williamson, the story is something like this: coming out of the 1960s, the American state had more than enough tax revenue, because, since tax brackets were fixed, inflation had led to an unplanned increase in collected taxes – a phenomenon known as brackets creep. There was an opening, and American business seized it by organizing. New grassroots business association were started, new lobbying techniques were deployed. This period is when the anti-tax rhetoric we are now familiar came to the fore: taxes are stifling innovation, etc. These claims sounded bizarre in that time, since clearly industry was already innovating, nevertheless they succeeded. Williamson:

At the end of the day, the fact is that mass public opinion isn’t what causes politics to happen. Politics is not a public opinion poll; it’s the mobilization of organized interests through a party system. So you shouldn’t expect things that most people believe to automatically become law. 

If you have been paying attention to the current debate about inequalities, you will be familiar with the argument that these regressive tax cuts of the Reagan-Thatcher era kicked off a self-reinforcing loop of growing inequality. Taxed less, rich people became faster at accumulating wealth, which they used to buy political power and influence, which they used to avoid taxes even more through introducing loopholes and straight-up reducing tax rates. Also, this where CEO pays started to skyrocket: nobody had much to gain by increasing CEO pay when the state got to keep 90% of the increase. With the tax cuts, executives were much more incentivized to use their bargaining power to extract more money from the companies, and again this contributed to rising inequalities.

But here is what I, at least, had not perceived: this is also when budget deficit becomes important in the US, for the first time since World War 2. And why is that? Because, according to Williamson, these tax cuts were kept “off the books”. They were not immediately financed by slashing social security programmes, or increasing taxes for the working people: rather they were funded by issuing federal debt.

This move had far-reaching consequences. First, it defanged the opposition to the tax cuts. Working class Americans did not immediately feel the pain of this regressive distribution, and basically no one without training in economics could see that pain coming. Williamson:

If you look at the George W. Bush era, this was a very conscious strategy. In principle, you could have taken the surpluses of that era and used them to shore up Social Security or do any of a number of other things. If you look at memos within the Bush administration, it was very clearly stated that in going to the voters to cut taxes in this very regressive way, they had to say there were no tradeoffs at all. Fiscally, barring the costs of debt and interest, there were no immediate consequences.

And later, of course, it left us with the permanent threat of unsustainable public debt to justify austerity even by politicians that do not present as conservative. “Mistakes were made by previous governments. Now we have no choice but sacrifice your welfare system to the financial markets, lest our country becomes insolvent and has to default on its debt, with dire consequences for us all”. Again, this narrative is hard to attack without invoking advanced economic concepts, like Modern Monetary Theory.

So that’s how an important part of the economic landscape that we live in, the “tax cuts for rich people, austerity for the working class” combo was first shaped. But Williamson’s main point here is that taxation is the price of democracy (also the title of her latest book):

And that’s because democracy isn’t just being able to vote; it’s people having the power to actually make change to their government. And if the government doesn’t have enough money to act, then, even if you can vote, it’s inconsequential.

The book shows that, since John Lackland’s Magna Charta in 1215, taxation and representation go together, and the former leads the latter. When democracy grows, taxes go up, “because, of course, the taxpayers can now have a say in what the government is doing”; the freest countries today have high taxation levels, whereas taxes are low in authoritarian states.

The corollary of this story is this: conservatives since circa 1980 have been taking loans that they had no intention to repay, using our democracies as a collateral that can be repossessed, like in a mortgage. In the short term, their tax cuts created a benefit for themselves which proved to be cumulative. And, by being kept “off the books” , they reduced the power of government to be effective and created a group of wealthy people who – because they pay next to no taxes – are free riding on the public goods financed by the rest of us, just like the wealthy owners of holiday homes threatened by the 2026 wildfires in the French peninsula of Cap Ferret benefited from the firefighting services paid for by everyone else. Democracies kept going, so far. But this debt is long-term unsustainable. With it, the wealthy class is actively eroding social cohesion and democracy itself. I can only hope it can, at some point, be held accountable. Not only in moral terms, but also in financial ones, by paying its share of taxes.

Photo credit: Mael Dubie/EPA/Shutterstock under fair use

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *